What Is the AAA?
The American Arbitration Association is a nonprofit organization that administers arbitration and mediation proceedings. Founded in 1926, it is the largest and most widely recognized arbitration provider in the United States. Millions of contracts — including most major carrier, delivery, and gig economy agreements — name the AAA as the required arbitration forum.
The AAA does not decide your case. It administers the process: appointing arbitrators, managing document exchanges, and scheduling hearings. The appointed arbitrator decides the outcome.
For contractors, the most relevant AAA ruleset is the Employment Arbitration Rules or, in some cases, the Commercial Arbitration Rules. Your contract will specify which applies.
Which Rules Apply to Your Case?
The rules that govern your arbitration determine filing fees, discovery rights, and procedural protections. Two rulesets cover most contractor disputes:
Employment Arbitration Rules
Apply when the dispute arises from an employment or employment-like relationship. Many contractor disputes qualify, particularly in delivery and gig work. These rules include stronger consumer protections and lower fees for the claimant.
Commercial Arbitration Rules
Apply to business-to-business disputes. More common in freight and trucking contractor agreements. Filing fees are higher, but procedures are robust and allow for full document discovery.
If you're unsure which rules apply, read your contract's arbitration clause carefully. If it doesn't specify, contact the AAA directly — they will advise on the applicable ruleset.
How to File a Demand for Arbitration
Filing is done online through the AAA's case filing portal. You will need:
- ✓The completed Demand for Arbitration form (available on the AAA website)
- ✓A copy of the arbitration clause from your contract
- ✓A clear statement of your claim — what happened, how much you're owed, and why
- ✓Your filing fee payment
- ✓A copy of all supporting documents you want to file with the demand
Once filed, the AAA will notify the company and begin the arbitrator appointment process. The company must respond within 14 days under most rulesets.
AAA Fees and Cost Allocation
Under AAA Employment Rules, the claimant (you) pays a filing fee of approximately $300 for most contractor disputes. The company pays the arbitrator's fees, which typically range from $1,500–$3,000 for a single hearing day.
Under AAA Commercial Rules, fee allocation depends on the contract, but most arbitration clauses specify that the company bears arbitration costs above a nominal amount — because the company drafted the clause and cannot use cost barriers to discourage legitimate disputes.
Fee waivers are available for claimants who demonstrate financial hardship. Contact the AAA directly if filing fees present a barrier.
ClaimGuard Pro
Need your arbitration packet ready?
The Full Case Package gives you a complete arbitration submission — timeline, exhibit index, and damages summary.
The AAA Process Step by Step
1. File the Demand
Submit through the AAA portal. Include your contract, claim statement, and evidence.
2. Company Response
The company has 14–21 days to respond. If they don't, the AAA may proceed to appoint an arbitrator and schedule the hearing anyway.
3. Arbitrator Selection
The AAA sends both parties a list of potential arbitrators. Each side can strike names they object to and rank their preferences. The AAA appoints from the remaining candidates.
4. Preliminary Hearing
A brief conference — usually 30–60 minutes — to set the discovery schedule, hearing date, and document exchange deadlines.
5. Document Discovery
Both sides exchange relevant documents. You can request the company's internal records, complaint files, and damage reports during this phase.
6. Arbitration Hearing
Present your case. Walk the arbitrator through your timeline, exhibits, and damages calculation. Respond to the company's position.
7. Award
The arbitrator issues a written decision within 30 days. The award is final and enforceable in any federal or state court.
Winning Strategy for Contractors
Contractors who win arbitration share common traits:
✓ They organized their evidence before filing
Every exhibit numbered, every date verified, every dollar amount documented.
✓ They sent a demand letter before filing
This shows good-faith effort and often prompts settlement. Arbitrators take note when one party tried to resolve before escalating.
✓ They understood the company's weakness
Most companies issue chargebacks and damage claims without complete documentation. Expose the gaps in their evidence, not just defend your own conduct.
✓ They were professional throughout
Angry, emotional presentations weaken credibility. Arbitrators respond to calm, organized, evidence-driven presentations.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the AAA have a consumer fee waiver program?
Yes. Under the AAA Consumer Due Process Protocol, if your filing fee would present a financial hardship, you can apply for a waiver or reduction. Contact AAA's fee waiver department directly.
Can I file for arbitration if my contract doesn't name the AAA?
Your contract must name a specific arbitration provider, or you must agree on one with the company. If the contract is silent, you may be able to petition a court to appoint an arbitrator.
What if the company refuses to participate in arbitration?
If your contract requires arbitration and the company refuses, you can file a motion in court to compel arbitration. Courts routinely enforce valid arbitration clauses.
Can I get attorney's fees in arbitration?
It depends on your contract and applicable law. Under some state statutes and certain AAA rules, a prevailing party can recover attorney fees. Your contract's arbitration clause may also address this.
Ready to file? Get your case organized first.
ClaimGuard Pro's Full Case Package gives you everything you need to walk into AAA arbitration prepared.